How Premium Branding and Sustainability Drive Consumer Behavior: Insights from Saratoga® and Primo Brands

A blue bottle of Saratoga Sparkling Water placed next to a bowl of fresh figs and a pair of brown gloves, set in a rustic outdoor setting

Introduction

The hospitality industry is undergoing a transformation, driven by an increasing consumer demand for sustainability without compromising luxury. Premium brands have a unique opportunity to lead this change, setting new standards for responsible consumption while maintaining their exclusivity and high-end appeal.

A recent webinar, hosted by Saratoga® and Primo Brands, brought together industry leaders to discuss how premium branding and sustainability can intersect to shape consumer behaviors. With insights from Ed Ferguson, Chief Sustainability Officer at Primo Brands, and Jan Lucas, Vice President of Strategic Sourcing and Partnerships at Sage Hospitality, the discussion highlighted how luxury experiences can seamlessly integrate sustainability to influence purchasing decisions and long-term brand loyalty.

The Power of Premium Branding in Hospitality

For over 150 years, Saratoga® has been synonymous with excellence in the hospitality sector. Known for its signature blue glass bottles, the brand has built a legacy of quality, craftsmanship, and sophistication. But beyond aesthetics, premium branding has a psychological influence on consumer perception.

When guests encounter Saratoga® water in high-end restaurants or luxury hotels, they associate it with quality, exclusivity, and attention to detail. This premium positioning is a powerful tool—one that not only elevates a guest’s experience but also fosters long-term brand loyalty. As Ferguson pointed out, taste, provenance, and heritage are essential factors in defining a luxury product, and Saratoga embodies all three.

However, in today’s market, premium status alone is not enough. Consumers are becoming increasingly mindful of sustainability, and brands must align luxury with responsibility to remain relevant.

Sustainability as a Competitive Advantage

Primo Brands, the parent company of Saratoga®, has taken proactive steps to integrate sustainability into its operations. Water stewardship, responsible sourcing, and sustainable packaging are at the core of its strategy, ensuring that premium brands can maintain their high standards while minimizing their environmental impact.

Ferguson explained that sustainability isn’t always the primary driver behind a consumer’s purchase of a luxury product, but it often plays a subconscious role in brand preference. Consumers are drawn to brands that reflect their values, even if they aren’t explicitly seeking sustainable options. By making sustainability an integral part of the brand’s identity—rather than just an added feature—premium brands can influence long-term purchasing behaviors.

Sustainability in Luxury Hospitality

Luxury hotels and fine dining establishments have an important role to play in reinforcing sustainable behavior among consumers. According to Jan Lucas of Sage Hospitality, premium hospitality brands are actively integrating sustainability into the guest experience—without compromising on comfort or exclusivity.

For instance, Sage Hospitality has committed to eliminating single-use plastics by 2024, opting instead for reusable and biodegradable alternatives. This initiative extends to their partnership with Saratoga, whose elegant glass bottles align perfectly with the hotel’s commitment to sustainability while maintaining a premium aesthetic.

But sustainability in hospitality goes beyond just eliminating plastic. Lucas highlighted how luxury hotels are creating immersive experiences that educate and engage guests, such as:

  • Sourcing transparency: Ensuring guests know where their water, food, and amenities come from.
  • Sustainable storytelling: Weaving sustainability into the hotel’s brand narrative, making it an integral part of the guest journey.
  • Eco-conscious amenities: From biodegradable coffee pods to refillable water stations, hotels are rethinking the guest experience with a sustainable mindset.

Shifting Consumer Behavior Through Experience

One of the most fascinating aspects of the discussion was the idea that luxury experiences influence consumer behavior beyond the hotel stay. When guests experience a premium product in a fine dining restaurant or a five-star hotel, they are more likely to seek out that product in their everyday lives.

This phenomenon—sometimes referred to as the carryover effect—suggests that brands experienced in luxury settings have a direct influence on consumer purchasing behavior at home. If a guest enjoys Saratoga water in an upscale environment, they are more inclined to purchase it for their home, reinforcing the brand’s positioning and creating a long-term relationship with the consumer.

Moreover, when consumers associate a brand with responsible practices, it strengthens their loyalty. A premium brand that aligns with sustainability not only appeals to eco-conscious consumers but also enhances its reputation among all demographics, making it a more attractive choice overall.

The Future of Sustainability in Luxury Hospitality

Despite the progress, challenges remain in fully integrating sustainability into premium hospitality. According to Lucas, the biggest obstacles include:

  • Balancing sustainability with luxury expectations: Guests expect impeccable service, but also demand responsible practices.
  • Retrofitting historic properties: Many high-end hotels operate in historic buildings, making eco-friendly upgrades more complex.
  • Waste reduction and packaging innovation: Brands like Primo Brands are exploring new ways to enhance recycling rates and develop refillable solutions.

However, opportunities are emerging. From biogreen partnerships that convert food waste into organic fertilizer to hotel programs that encourage guests to opt out of daily housekeeping in exchange for tree planting, the hospitality industry is continuously innovating to align sustainability with premium experiences.

The conversation between Saratoga®, Primo Brands, and Sage Hospitality demonstrated a powerful insight: luxury and sustainability are no longer separate concepts—they are intertwined. Brands that successfully merge high-end experiences with responsibility and purpose will define the future of hospitality.

For hoteliers, restaurateurs, and brand strategists, the key takeaway is clear: consumers are drawn to premium brands that align with their values. Whether through responsible sourcing, sustainable packaging, or immersive eco-conscious experiences, premium brands must continue to lead the way in shaping consumer behavior.

By doing so, they not only enhance guest loyalty and elevate their brand reputation but also contribute to a more sustainable future—one luxury experience at a time.

Join the Conversation

As the industry continues to evolve, staying informed on sustainability trends is crucial.

Watch the full webinar recording
Do not miss our upcoming webinars

Webinar announcement featuring Ed Ferguson and Jan Lucas, discussing sustainability in luxury branding, sponsored by Saratoga.